After about 5 min's of frustration i checked somepage. Only somepage was missing the black pepper! So i was going all over the place goin "Wtf!!!" till i combined the 2 anyways.
Correct synth:
Fire crystal
Beaugreen Sautee x1 Bird Egg x1 Black Pepper x1 Danceshroom x1 Pie Dough x1 Rock Salt x1 Selbina Milk x1 Stone Cheese x1