ohmikeghod the Venerable wrote:
Wondroustremor the Flatulent wrote:
(What I said)
Sorry, but this is just another way of saying "we raid other end-game guilds for members", or (alternatively) "We aren't accepting new members". I don't see anyone making it through "DM/Scholo/Strat/BRD/LBRS/UBRS runs" without being part of a group. The same goes for being MC/BWL attuned or having done Ony without a good group. My advise is to stay away from guilds that do this kind of recruitment.
You know what? You're right, in a way. I tend to find there's quite a bit of movement with some members of raiding guilds, especially the "top-tier" guilds. Headhunting is a big part of business. However, I've come to realise that there's a difference between a guild that looks for someone willing to take steps themselves and a guild that demands what is only available from other raiding guilds.
A lot of players use endgame guilds like stepping stones, which I don't really approve of, but it happens quite frequently. The guild I'm currently in is casual, but doing endgame instances and some raids, with a view to getting serious about MC and AQ in the new year. The big issue is that we've been having certain guilds that have a better-geared player base (and thus, able to do more in terms of endgame content) headhunt players from our guild after they get a certain amount of gear. They come into our guild, profess their love for the social part of it, but as soon as someone from a guild that's doing BWL hints that a position is open in their guild, said guildie drops us like a hot potato, pushing back the timetable for us to be able to do those raids a little farther. What really is irksome is when people come into a mid-level guild, get geared up for the good of the guild, get that last piece of tier 1, and quit that day.
However, it doesn't take a full raiding guild to get your Tier 0- that can be done with some luck and skill, even in PuGs. Most of the attunements can be done over time in PuGs as well, over time. Onyxia
can be done, but not without lots of time invested and a willingness to accept PuG wipes often. I respect the fact that raiding guilds don't want to have to take a person who has nothing to offer, and run them through attunements, and then gear them up, only to risk losing them to the next guild up the ladder- so I realise why they have some standards. Time is money, and nobody likes investing money into something that's going to be stolen away at some unknown date.
To use myself as an example, I have been able to get a few pieces of my tier 0 through farming for gold, buying the parts on AH, and I've gotten several other decent items of gear through my casual guild. I'm also picking up my Amulet of the Darkmoon next month, thanks to some aggressive farming of turnin rewards and shrewd purchases of dense stones. I pass them on to a friend who turns them into dense grinding stones, and in trade, I help his alt with any Elite-level quests he needs done that week. I was accepted into my guild after the old one went because they saw that I had put time into turning my T0 into 0.5, and had done other high-level instances to get some decent gear.
So it's possible to get applicants who can gear up without stealing the members of other guilds. It's just that it seems that headhunting is done more often than not, and that's unfortunate.