In UBRS last week, we had a guy ninja Myrmidon's Signet. We started off badly, and in the first room with the adjoining smaller rooms, we wiped after someone managed to aggro more than one room. Somehow the rogue managed to survive (I still suspect that he saw everything going pearshaped and ran out of the instance, since we were still pretty close to the portal, or else he had a very successful Vanish). While I was dead, I saw Myrmidon's Signet pop up! I informed the raid, some of whom had already released since we didn't have a live rezzer. Long story short, the rogue rolled Need on it while we were all running back to our bodies, and the two warriors got back in the instance to find out that the Rogue had won it. We told him he had to give it up, and he refused. Basically, he said that I didn't need it because it was a melee ring, and he fairly won it in the roll. When the Warriors asked him to /roll against them, he still refused, and left the raid.
It was in the AH by the time we got back from the run.
Edited, Nov 26th 2006 8:48am by Wondroustremor