Forum Settings
       
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Cross Counters, you wanna know their advantage? I'll tell UFollow

#1 Dec 10 2004 at 11:24 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
611 posts
For one it's the simple fact that they are great weapons, and before the Spartans nothing is even close to touching them. And +113 delay on the Spartans? Obviously they are great 50-58 because nothing is in their range, but I farmed for well over a month and cooked kabobs to get them and I'm sooooo glad I did. Even though the WHOLE time I was skeptical of whether or not all my time would pay off and I'd be impressed once I was able to buy them.

First XP party, a solid 15 DMG per hand INCREASE over my previous weapon, I dunno which it was, but it wasn't crap, I always had good stuff, which is why I farmed for the CC's. Anyway, it was better, but not jaw dropping.

Then I went on and entered a 50 cap ballista. And let me tell you now, a MNK decked out in nice gear with Cross Counters is the end all be all in a 50 cap ballista. I mean you can one on one anybody anytime anywhere any circumstance. The xp party is AWESOME and the CC do get the job done....but come on, what's my gratifying than BLASTING a cocky *** whatever for about a 700 Rage Fist and he's an even match ^^.

I do ok in the 60 cap, but I'm under lvl'd, but as far as the CC at lvl 50, it's just sick how nasty that weapon is at that lvl. I was in 2 ballista last night, 50 caps. The first we were winning by such a large margin I just quit playing the last 15 minutes, it was 80 something to 1. Then when it was over I had placed 3rd in scoring, and a little thing popped up and told me I was on track to becoming the Ballistar . Well, I had never heard of this previously, so I was pissed I didn't go all out for the whole ballista.

But, lessons learned right? So I go register for the next ballista and go full tilt on their asses the whole fight, and we were out numbered. We slaughtered them, I had about 35-40 KO's and score I dunno how many petra. Anyway when it was all said and done I was the MVP by more than 40 points and I'm well on my way to becoming my servers first Ballistar ^^

And I'd like to think a LARGE part of that is the time I took to get my Cross Counters. Because, they are, very over powered at lvl 50, it's just a fact.
____________________________
Dragich-Hume-Unicorn
75 Monk
75 Ninja
75 Warrior
62 Corsair
61 Dark Knight

Lightnlng-Taru-Unicorn
75 Black Mage
62 Summoner
#2 Dec 10 2004 at 11:30 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,377 posts
{Thats interesting}, but as effen and many others say the CC's out dmg spartan cesti by like .0005 dmg and i have found out for myself it is true after pt'ing with a mnk that is a lvl above me and i was doing the same dmg,but he was attaking -->||<-- this much faster.
#3 Dec 10 2004 at 11:34 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
611 posts
Well that should be obvious right?

CC dmg +19
Spartan dmg +20

15, 16, 17, 18, 19,< 20

and you can't use spartans in a 50 cap ballista

and I didn't comment on the 60 caps yet because I'm underlvld
But I do counter often.

____________________________
Dragich-Hume-Unicorn
75 Monk
75 Ninja
75 Warrior
62 Corsair
61 Dark Knight

Lightnlng-Taru-Unicorn
75 Black Mage
62 Summoner
#4 Dec 10 2004 at 4:43 PM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
i had CCs for a while, and when i got past 70 i sold them back. why? 1.8m for mnd gear >>>>> cross counters.

once you get to 67, Vishnu's Cesti are god. youll know once you get there and start fighting bones more.

also, i got avengers at lvl 73... and my god they own. i love them.
#5 Dec 10 2004 at 5:41 PM Rating: Good
***
1,574 posts
I hate to break it to you, but Avengers suck. Hello, +18/96? CC and TMH+2 blow these away. Vishnu aren't any good until you hit 75 and get MA6 bonus, and then they are on par with TM2 and CC. By then you should be looking to pick up Indras, if you haven't already.

I wouldn't recommend focusing on MND gear until you're going up against stuff that you can't melee, which is usually post-70.
____________________________
Aurik - Asura
75mnk/60nin/50blm/41war/38thf/37whm
100+3 Clothcraft
100+3 Leathercraft
95.2+2 Bone
100+3 Alchemy
#6 Dec 10 2004 at 6:36 PM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
vishnus are far superior to CCs... i made the switch at 72 and the damage output was way higher.

i had the ability to sell the CCs cuz avengers are FREE, and i only melee on trigger hunts anyway. at 75, MNK is such a machine i really dont focus on meleeing anymore, its just not worth the effort. ill be the first to admit my melee gear is ******, but i can still pull aggro consistently (which is why i dont upgrade it). its not about your gear guys.

i just sit back and cheer on all the idiot mnks on my server that decided to upgrade their melee gear. go go HNM whiff fest.
#7 Dec 10 2004 at 7:20 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
258 posts
I used to think CC would last me forever, as in... never have to get something else.

Then again, it's the same thing I thought about Ochiudo's Kote.
____________________________
"Sure, Rangers can see everything with widescan. But can they see why kids love Cinnamon Toast Crunch?"
#8 Dec 10 2004 at 7:24 PM Rating: Excellent
***
1,574 posts
Number crunching:
Base DMG = (HTH Skill) / 9.1 * 0.9 + 3
HTH@72 = 261
Base DMG = 28.81

Vishnu Cesti
Dmg +7
Delay +0
STR+2 DEX+2 Accuracy+4
@72 Delay: 320+0 = 320
@72 Damage: 35.81
@72 Ratio: 0.112

Cross-counters
Dmg +19
Delay +96
Accuracy +3
@72 Delay: 320+96 = 416
@72 Damage: 47.81
@72 Ratio: 0.115

Notes:
- WS damage is significantly higher with Cross-counters due to higher Base Damage.
- As level decreases, Cross-counters win by a larger margin. As level increases, Cross-counters win by a narrower margin.

"Far superior" my foot.

Edited, Fri Dec 10 19:27:48 2004 by aurikan
____________________________
Aurik - Asura
75mnk/60nin/50blm/41war/38thf/37whm
100+3 Clothcraft
100+3 Leathercraft
95.2+2 Bone
100+3 Alchemy
#9 Dec 10 2004 at 7:59 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
298 posts
I know I shouldn't still want them at 63, but I do. Someone tell me to stick with Spartan Cesti! lol
____________________________
Gaar, Hume
Carbuncle Server / Kalm LS

Chi blasting HNMs, Monk macros and MND gear
#10 Dec 11 2004 at 4:02 AM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
1. you may have crunched the numbers, but you didnt take into account that the speed is higher and you will output more asuran fists.

2. you dont even know if that equation is correct.

3. vishnu's gives STR and ACC... take that into account.

4. youre lvl 61, until you can actually equip them and can tell me you like cross counters better, you shouldnt be crunching the numbers.
#11 Dec 11 2004 at 4:27 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
802 posts
CC is good because:

1) It last for the whole damn game, if you don't care about weapons

2) Its the best low-high level weapon

3) You can use it for BC50 and 60

If you want a good weapon, so far I think Kasier Kunckles
+20dmg +86Delay +3chr +3vit +3Acc is the best weapon a Lv75 can get.

Maybe Meteor cest is good too. Anyone with Vish tried using Meteor?

O ya I forgot. I'm using shiva claws now.

Edited, Sat Dec 11 04:30:26 2004 by Humster
____________________________

[ffxivsig]406787[/ffxivsig]
#12 Dec 11 2004 at 4:57 AM Rating: Excellent
***
1,574 posts
You don't output more WS with Vishnu because TP gain is directly proportional to weapon delay. If you consider +1 str == +1 dmg, then @72, the ratio for vishnu becomes 0.119, or ever-so-slightly better than Cross-counters, if you ignore the whole WS damage suckage thing. It's definitely not "far superior".

As for calling my level into play, that's not an argument, that's a fallacy. Let me turn it around: you're 75. How do you not already know that TP gain is related to weapon delay? How can you legitimately claim that Avengers are awesome, when they are strictly worse than Cross-counters? How can you level through the whole game with only one sniper ring max and claim to have hit mobs "fine"? Why is it every post I see from you here advocates being stingy and cheap?

Do you see what I'm doing here? I'm calling into question your competency. It may be effective, but it isn't a very valid argument, certainly no more valid that "you're only level 61, what could you possibly know?".
____________________________
Aurik - Asura
75mnk/60nin/50blm/41war/38thf/37whm
100+3 Clothcraft
100+3 Leathercraft
95.2+2 Bone
100+3 Alchemy
#13 Dec 11 2004 at 5:46 AM Rating: Decent
**
500 posts
i guess ill give it a shot at ending the whole best weapon thing.......................Spharai

i know i know they are hard as hell to get and they are super expensive to upgrade bet hey its not impossible^^
____________________________
the monk i wish i had they playtime to be:
http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?174022
[ffxivsig]402818[/ffxivsig]
#14 Dec 11 2004 at 2:06 PM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
youre using math to discount different tactics than the one you like. i used cross counters for a pretty long time, and when i switched to vishnu's they were obviously better. 'ws suckage'? when i finally made the switch, the difference in asuran fists was a mere 100 damage tops. its just something you have to try, maybe you should leave windurst long enuff to gain some lvls and try it out.

if i remember correctly, at 72 the TP difference between CCs and vishnu's was maybe .5-1 tp per hit. nothing majorly notable. how can you say that avengers ARENT better than CCs when you arent even high enuff to use them? i dont understand why everyone else needs a major acc boost, i never cried over a few whiffs here and there. how am i stingy and cheap? i use a different playing style, things change from 61 to 75. youll know if you try getting there.

keep crunching the numbers, youll make yourself feel smarter. but when you get to 2-3 mnk parties in king ranperres tomb youll feel stupid when the mnk with vishnus is doing the most damage.
#15 Dec 11 2004 at 8:37 PM Rating: Excellent
***
1,574 posts
I'm not going to bother arguing with you if all you're going to say is "you're level 61, I'm level 75, therefore I'm right". It's pointless.

I don't want the openminded readers to get the wrong impression, so I'll point them to this thread on KI, where well-respected posters have this to say about Vishnus:

"I know a few people who are rather fond of these, but their equipment choices are also a little... unusual, so their opinion could be considered suspect. I used Narasimha's Cesti for a while to get a feel for them and was completely unimpressed. The increase in speed didn't seem to counter-balance the loss to damage and it really showed when my weapon skills were doing as much damage as they did back at level 50. Most of the best Monks that I've seen try these almost immediately resell them and pick up a pair of Feral Fangs or Cross-Counters, as their budget permits." -- Onorgul, 72

"Its really just to show off a semi hundred fists. TP gain is good, but your dmg suffers a huge hit." -- Xaijin, 75

"they aren't really made for exping, they really shine for farming." -- Torahi, 74

The only person who speaks up in favor of vishnus also thinks that Dragon Kick damage isn't affected by weapon damage.

Edited, Sat Dec 11 20:40:36 2004 by aurikan
____________________________
Aurik - Asura
75mnk/60nin/50blm/41war/38thf/37whm
100+3 Clothcraft
100+3 Leathercraft
95.2+2 Bone
100+3 Alchemy
#16 Dec 12 2004 at 10:41 PM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
again ill say its just something you need to try. seems like almost all the monks on my server like them after using them. after getting to 75 i prefer avengers, before i had them i didnt want them, and i didnt think they would be as good as cross counters were. sometimes though, i think they might have hidden effects because they seem to do a lot better than anything else ive used. if they do have any i would say critical rate +, thats the thing i noticed right away was more criticals. but what do i know, im just a rambler.

still trying to get indra katars... steam cleaner on siren was broken for like 2-3 weeks and no one could pop him. also its pretty rare, weve killed it quite a few times and never seen them ><;.
#17 Dec 13 2004 at 4:04 AM Rating: Decent
***
2,038 posts
Quote:
As for calling my level into play, that's not an argument, that's a fallacy. Let me turn it around: you're 75. How do you not already know that TP gain is related to weapon delay? How can you legitimately claim that Avengers are awesome, when they are strictly worse than Cross-counters? How can you level through the whole game with only one sniper ring max and claim to have hit mobs "fine"? Why is it every post I see from you here advocates being stingy and cheap?

Do you see what I'm doing here? I'm calling into question your competency. It may be effective, but it isn't a very valid argument, certainly no more valid that "you're only level 61, what could you possibly know?".


Aurik, I love you.

That is the most words I have ever seen used to express "stfu noob!" in my life.

But seriously, the Vishnu's suck even for farming. Max damage per punch was 60-70.. +0 delay isn't a lot when you consider you already have 300 base delay at level 75. Like it or not that is 5 whole seconds.

If you don't think +12 damage makes a huge difference you are a noob.

Think of it this way. Cross counters let you do approx 48 more actual damage/round with only 1.5 second more delay.
#18 Dec 13 2004 at 5:04 AM Rating: Decent
**
565 posts
cc is not worth the money
____________________________
Alexander
Monk 75 / Warrior 75 / Ranger 75 / Black Mage 75
http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?9466
#19 Dec 13 2004 at 7:44 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,014 posts
Yes it is.
____________________________
BRD75 / NIN75 / MNK75 / WAR63

N'yar~
lolblog, complete with vanity pictures!
#20 Dec 13 2004 at 7:58 AM Rating: Decent
***
1,382 posts
(I'm a warrior btw) One day I was looking through the H2H weapon list and I noticed something curious. That CC's have the highest damage for a great many levels (something crazy, like 15 or 20), for the same or lower delay. And being someone who uses one handed weapons, I know base damage and str are very important.

Edited, Mon Dec 13 07:58:56 2004 by choryukami
____________________________
Kamatsu (Shiva) Hume, Bastok Rank 10, Windurst Rank 7
Attack: http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?1381
Defense: http://ffxi.allakhazam.com/profile.xml?24744
Steel Cyclone Complete. Decimation Complete.
Call of Destiny: http://www.turnstylestudios.com
#21 Dec 13 2004 at 9:19 AM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
81 posts
If the arguement is Vishnu's Cesti Vs Cross Counter's..

I'd vote for CC's..

Only reason why is because I'm a big WS Person and since my HNM LS has 5+ Blm's most of our Dmg comes from MB's. And me out tp gaining my sc partner (Warrior's Usaully) doesn't help much.

I can see where people would say Vishnu's are better. I used the Narasimha's (No Vish. in stock at the time) during a Item god hunt, and ya I loved the Dmg/Delay ratio. On NM's like Zipnaca who has high Evasion + High Def there perfect. On NM's like him you want to depend on your DoT and..

Narasimha's + Bard Songs + Haste is great on it. (I out Damaged all the classes there except the only Blm who MB'ed 3 times)

Would like to state that I've never owned a pair of CC's so...
<,<

I was gimp when I Lv'ed now @ 70's I'm doing my best To pimp out my Monk (Combo of +eva and +str) and Am trying for my indra Katar's, 0/3 on Steamcleaner very dumb drop rate >.<

Question: Has any one tried this combo..

Brown Belt (8%) + Fuma Kyahan (3%) + Byakko's Haidate (5%) + Panzer Mask (2%) + Haste Spell + Vishnu's Cesti

I've Never tried it but I Wouldn't be surprised if this out dmg'ed CC's
____________________________
{Zero Lv75 Monk} - {Chi Blast Gear} - {My Goal}
Highest Chi Blast ~> 1540
{Subligar}{Monk}{Key}

#22 Dec 14 2004 at 12:47 AM Rating: Default
*
68 posts
id like to try it but my LS is gay and ill never have haidate. weve got 3 to drop so far and they let ******* bards lot on it...
#23 Dec 14 2004 at 2:18 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
*
94 posts
God damn it i read thru the damn thread hoping to see some smart info and all i see are flame wars, damn guys.

Anyways, Im lvl 64 i used the cross counters for a while until 2 high level monks (75, one with a kirins osode and several other jobs at 75) just told me, CC's are not worth it, get spartan cesti, even if maybe in DoT you may do more damage with the CC's, at lvl 65 you will become a skillchain closer and skillchain damage is related to weapon damage. so sparants would make a bit stronger skillchains closers.

I really think they are right on track, the good thing from the cross counters is the counter, thats the most underrated thing about the damn weapon. get a pair of aikido ******** 2 avenger earrings and the cross counters and go "hundred fist" an exp mob with counterstance on. you'll see what i mean.

As far as whats better, CC's or Spartan Cesti. I had my doubts... but now I am sure Spartans are overall better for the level you get them in.
#24 Dec 14 2004 at 2:55 PM Rating: Good
Scholar
***
1,689 posts
I have a question.

Does 1 STR really give 1 DMG?

If so, then without a doubt Tropical Punches +1 would be the weapon of choice post-61.

With enough accuracy gear from Weapon, Body, and Neck slots, I can afford to pump my STR up to +32.

Without enough accuracy from those slots, I would have to equip Sniper's and Life Belt which would drop me down to a STR+11.

That's a 21 STR difference there. Isn't that better than the 17 damage difference between CC and Tropical Punches +1?
____________________________
Hinwei :: Asura Server :: RETIRED
56WAR :: 65MNK :: 61THF
Bonecraft 70.2+1 :: Leathercraft 43.0 :: Alchemy 56.0

Partying Guide
#25 Dec 14 2004 at 9:03 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
***
1,072 posts
This topic seems to come up several every few months... And the pure haste monk has come up before (Lets leave MNK/DRG haste warrior out of it this time ^^).

Quote:
Question: Has any one tried this combo..

Brown Belt (8%) + Fuma Kyahan (3%) + Byakko's Haidate (5%) + Panzer Mask (2%) + Haste Spell + Vishnu's Cesti


When looking at base DOT comparing Faster and weaker hits VS. slower heavier hits seem very close. As for WS the heavy hit wins out obviously, but the fast hits will gain TP faster. We know the tp gain per hit is lower, but on high evasion enemies a "miss" counts for a lot less when rapid punching, compared to winding up and missing with you big old "sunday punch". (I used Ben Grimm phrase on a forum... I feel so bad now >.<)

But after all is said and done, CC seem to be winning up to this point, primarily due to damage from skill chain closing. By how much I can't say...

"The kicking Monk"
The only good argument I heard for this was a kicking monk. Replace the fumas with wulong/dune footwear and with the added haste you will get more kicks in per fight. Kick damage is exclusively based on footwear (and str, etc) so the +0 from vishnu's means nothing here. The kicking boots outhit H2H weapons considerably (The dunes boots are equivalent to a +30 or even +40 weapon depending on who you ask)

So post 71 with "Kick II" do you kick enough for this setup to count for something? Kick seems to be 20% chance of triggering per attack round (10% per punch?). I get a kick in every 3-5 combat rounds as an L61 Noob. Is this drastically increased at 71? If so your number of kicks occuring in a fight would be scary, and this can balance out the value of Vishnus...

Dune boots scare me... check them out in the item database and every comment just goes on about how they make hate out of control due to overwhelming damage. So if Vishnus help milk more out of them, I'm onboard. ^^
#26 Dec 14 2004 at 9:08 PM Rating: Decent
Scholar
**
795 posts
There's a formula that uses your STR, attack, H2H skill and your WEAPON DAMAGE (>_>;;) when factoring in your damage per hit. Using tropical punches+1 would completely waste the STR you added. Hand2Hand weapon damage is very sensitive. There is a reason why Spartan Cesti are 600k-1mil. ^^

Tropical Punches are expensive as they are because they are rare and an HQ.

Stick with an H2H weapon with damage from 18-20 depending on your delay preferences and other stats to think about.
____________________________
Fuertes
Melee Gear -- Chi Blast Gear --
Server: Cerberus
[b]Rank 10 // ZM Completed // CoP Completed
Galka
[b][orange]75 Monk 75 Samurai
« Previous 1 2
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 0 All times are in CDT