Quote:
Fact is, idiggory was wrong. Blizzard never said that Arthas was going to be defeatable outside of a raid. The closest they came to saying anything of the sort was that they wanted raid content to be more accessible. I challenge you (or idiggory) to quote me the line from the blue post or main WoW site saying that Blizzard intended to have the Lich King die outside of a raid.
And when people put forward their own ideas on the idea of an anti-climactic final showdown in a 5-man dungeon, it was idiggory that started the whole, "CASUALS ARE PEOPLE TOO!!" crusade.
They never said he'd be defeatable in a raid either. What they did say is that everyone would face him. True, that doesn't necessarily mean the casuals can kill him. But it doesn't mean that they won't either. I took the stance that I thought it was likely. You took the opposite stance. You didn't have any more information supporting your claim than I did.
And the argument wasn't about "will they," it was about "should they be able to."
And I like how you try and support your claim by saying I started a "crusade." If you look back to the first posts, my comments about "Blizzard said" have to do with there existing a LK fight, not a LK kill.
Other people then said they don't think that he should be killable in a 5-man. Actually, I'm pretty sure Anobix was the first one. We responded that we felt the opposite.
So, please, explain to me how I started a "crusade" for the casuals. Did I try and defend their right to experience the same lore as raiders? Yes. And if you reread my first posts, I asserted the possiblity that neither the 5 nor 25 man could kill him. I just didn't want casuals to be left with the "setback" story.
Actually, all I said was that I thought it was unfair that casuals were being cut out of the story. YOU were the first one to mention schedules, Aurelius, in the post that Mazra quoted.
So how about, instead of blaming me, you actually bother to know what you're talking about?
[EDIT]
Quote:
Aurelius, we were just exchanging hopes and wishes when you pulled in on your mighty and high horse telling us to go raid or gtfo.
This conversation, though, is over for my part. It's effectively degenerated into "no ur teh meanie!" fecal flinging and I don't need that. Judging by the ratings these last posts have gotten, I'd say others are getting tired of it as well. So let's just drop it here with an "aye aye, mr raider guy" and hope Blizzard might have second thoughts about limiting the storyline to only a certain part of their player base.
This. Seriously. Go reread the first page. I'm done, too. I'm not on this site to have someone bash me for things I haven't even done. I'm all for discussion (actually, I love it), and Mazra and I TRIED to have one with you. But, your own immaturity and turn to name-calling made that impossible. I would have been more than happy to consider your views if you even bothered to consider ours. Not once did Mazra and I say anything should be taken away from raiders. We never said anything about toning down difficulty, giving drops to lowbies or anything else. I would have been perfectly happy with a LK kill instance that had zero drops.
We merely want everyone to get the most out of the game they pay for.
And, honestly, this isn't about me being a casual and feeling left out. No, really. It isn't. Back before Ulduar was released I was 100% on the side that felt that hard modes should be implemented so they are actually hard. I'll probably never enter a hard mode. But I was still willing to support the idea of making the game for other players that do PvE for a challenge. Why? Because I want the game to be fun for everyone, not just me.
I'm out.
Edited, Oct 7th 2009 9:04pm by idiggory