This is just another WoW vs. EQ2 thread. They're always the longest because people like to beat this horse into the ground.
Here is a break down of both games from someone (me) who tried both games at low, mid, and high levels. Keep in mind I had no bias either...I enjoyed Diablo 2 and the Warcraft series just as much as Everquest.
Everquest 2 vs. World of Warcraft Graphics - EQ2
Gameplay - EQ2
Music/Sound - EQ2
Group Content - EQ2
Solo Content - WoW
End Game - EQ2
Tradeskill System - EQ2
Friendly Player Base - EQ2
Economy - EQ2
Quests - EQ2
Housing - EQ2
Lore - Even
Immersion - Even
Customization - EQ2
Congratulations! You have gained a new level in reviewing MMO's.
If you are a casual or impatient gamer who demands instant gratification then play World of Warcraft. The quests are not as involved and it's really easy to do stuff...even if you don't have a group. If you want a sense of accomplishment and have lots of time to play go EQ2. I don't care what Sony says...this game requires alot of time to do stuff.
If you are a diehard PvPer play WoW. I absolutley LOVE PvP. I played on a PvP server in the original EverQuest. I was hoping WoW was going to be the better game just so I could play PvP. Unforuntley I couldn't get over all the other things and that is why I play EQ2.
If you think both games stink you aren't alone. Brad McQuaid and the old Verant team now work for Sigil games and are in the process of developing a new MMO called Vanguard. You can see the official website at
http://www.vanguardsoh.com
____________________________
Destiny - Level 50 Warlock|27 Provisioner - Grobb
Marissa - Level 28 Shadowknight|20 Armorer - Grobb
Deviana - Level 12 Bard|10 Scholar - Grobb