Dronamidgard wrote:
If the goal of SE was to make it easy for players to move on from 11 to 14 I certainly do not understand how the advertised job system accomplishes their goal. Even without the aggravation and antipathy they have generated with their clumsy announcements and abominable costumer support I think they have engineered gauranteed dissatisfaction from ff11 players.
Practically everyone I know in this game has multiple jobs at 75 and one or more high level crafts. Having to level up two characters to max out 1 job and 1 trade skill just seems like a recipe for failure to me. Regardless of any other issues the announced job and crafting system really nerfed my interest in 14.
So far 14 seems like ffxi with better graphics and a gimped set of options for jobs and crafting. The ability to level multiple jobs on one character is just too good to retreat from. On this single feature, from my perspective, ff11 is superior to ff14. While this may not be an issue for people that have not played ff11 I just do not foresee how ff11 players could possibly be satisfied by the restrictions announced for ff14.
I'm not sure where you got "Having to level up two characters to max out 1 job and 1 trade skill" from but comparing job systems from game to game like that isn't fair, especially without more info on FFXIV. You have to consider the game as a whole instead of just transposing a feature from one to the other.
FFXI has a lot of check points (like subjobs, airship pass, level caps, etc.) which make starting a new character very unattractive. That's why being able to switch jobs on one character works so well. You still start at 1 though so that means leveling in the same zones again and again, even if your not redoing subjob quests.
Take a game like WoW however, which doesn't have those kind of road blocks and a one class per character system starts to make more sense. Yeah you repeat a lot of quests but since WoW levels differently in the end your basically doing the same thing.
Having a one class per character system can actually be freeing really, as you can try out different races without worrying about having to redo those major stepping stones.