Forum Settings
       
Reply To Thread

Miss this game =(Follow

#1 Aug 15 2005 at 6:02 PM Rating: Good
Hello all,

Its been about 2 years since i left EQ. One thing i have noticed is that many of the new MMOG's are more for the Casual gamer...they don't hold my interest like eq did nor do they have the content or IMO the community like EQ.

Recently i tried coming back to Eq... it was a very sad, depressing sight. Felwith was dead, CB had 2 people but no grps camping the TR like the old days, and PoK had 50 people in it.

What do you think it would take to get people back to EQ? What if SOE upgraded the games Graphics to match those of current MMOG's. I mean its not the content or the gameplay that i think lot of people left and actually i think if the graphics were greatly improved people would Leave WoW,FFXI, and even EQ2 to come back home =(

anyway , food for thought.
#2 Aug 15 2005 at 7:03 PM Rating: Good
***
2,198 posts
People aren't in the old zones not because of the graphics, but, as Joph has lamented several times, the old world experience and loot SUCK compared to what you can get in the newer areas. The only way they can spark interest in the old world zones is by 1. making them hotzones with large experience bonuses 2. upgrading the loot significantly 3. revamping the zone graphically.

We know from experience now that 3 just doesn't cut it. Mistmoore castle and Splitpaw are perfect examples. That means loot upgrades, and that's just not likely to happen at a significant pace.

There's also the problem that there just aren't that many TRUE newbies to EQ, and I guess that's what your post is really aimed at; how to get true newbies playing. Graphics MAY help there, but I think the EQ legacy will keep them from playing. Just think about the rep that EQ has: "Evercrack", "EQ-Widows", the "EQ suicide" reports, the EQ related child neglect reports, the crucade of Ben Stein against EQ, etc. Frankly, it scares a lot of people, or it scares the people that pay for the games said people play.
#3 Aug 15 2005 at 9:08 PM Rating: Decent
*
151 posts
Quote:
the crusade[sic] of Ben Stein against EQ


This peaked my interest. I'm a fan of Ben Stein, but never heard of him being anti-eq. Can you post a link?

Edited, Mon Aug 15 22:07:24 2005 by tchzarmok
#4 Aug 15 2005 at 9:14 PM Rating: Decent
You make great points and i gave you a big rate up for that. When i said update in graphics i didnt mean just as in this zone or that zone, i ment in the big picture... character graphics, game interaction ect.

The statement about "true newbies" is something pretty serious if you think about it. Peoples lives change they may not keep playing EQ for whatever reason, and since it has a very small appeal to newbies anymore its very sad to sit and watch something that was so amazing slowly die infront of my eyes. I don't know if you have tried EQ2 but IMO it has NO comparison to EQ1 other than the name. My point being there isn't another MMOG out there that IMO can compair to EQ1. These new MMOG's seems to all support the 'casual' gamer with the hp/mp regen on its own and the fast xp/lvl gains. That to me isn't a true MMOG.

Also when i was lvl'ing i should have added that i used the LFG tool and there were 3 people of lower lvl (lvls 1-20) looking for grp in thw whole world.

Was a sad sight.

Edited, Mon Aug 15 22:26:39 2005 by anfcollegeguy

Edited, Mon Aug 15 22:16:18 2005 by anfcollegeguy
#5 Aug 16 2005 at 8:30 AM Rating: Decent
*
222 posts
Do a little experiment. I am mainly on a low population server, Firiona Vie, where you are allowed ONE toon at a time, but it works.

Do a /who all 1 20, and see how many are NOT in the tutorial. Those that are, ask them if they are new players. 9 out of 10, close to 10 out of 10, they are re-rolls. When was the last time someone joined EQ with a new account, who had never played before? This is the real problem of EQ. No new blood. As players move away for whatever resons (new games, real life, boredom, even death), the actual numbers of thriving accounts is decreasing. Or so it seems.
#6 Aug 16 2005 at 8:40 AM Rating: Decent
The problem with most new MMO's is that they take all the gripes from players of everquest and try to "fix" them, SoE even did this with EQ2. What this does is break the system. I would like to say that even though SoE drives me up the freaking wall sometimes, with EQ1 they really got it right. If the game was easier, I would grow bored and quit playing.

For another MMO to be as successful as EQ, not just more players but being able to have 10 expansions and still doing great, they need to stick with the ground rules of EQ1. Anyone remember how level 30,35,40,45, and 51-59 SUCKED because they were "hell levels." Anyone remember the feeling of accomplishment after dinging out of one of those levels? I loved it, plus it ensured that people would just not do a continuous grind to the top.

The problem EQ1 has now is they never planned well for expansions. From the beginning they should have said that with every 3 expansions they old world zones would be updated a little. That way when, lets say, Luclin came out the original eq zones/mobs/items would be slightly updated to fit current Luclin standards. Then when Planes of Power is release Kunark gets a small revamp, LDoN releases and Velious is updated, etc. These don't have to me MAJOR updates, just enough to keep old world zones utilized.

I don't think anyone expected EQ to last as long as it has, therefore never came up with a good long term strategy.
#7 Aug 16 2005 at 9:55 AM Rating: Excellent
Liberal Conspiracy
*******
TILT
tchzarmok wrote:
This peaked my interest. I'm a fan of Ben Stein, but never heard of him being anti-eq. Can you post a link?
A few years back, 20/20 did a piece on EQ. One of the sillier bits was Mr. Stein talking about how his teenage son was "addicted" and had to be shipped off to some camp or hospital or whatever. At least Ms. Wooley's campaign can be explained by her grief but Stein just came across as some Hollywood nutbag who couldn't deal with his son playing video games by, say, taking away the computer or keeping an eye on his kid and instead shipped him off to let a shrink handle it.
____________________________
Belkira wrote:
Wow. Regular ol' Joph fan club in here.
#8 Aug 16 2005 at 11:30 AM Rating: Decent
You're all 100% correct in that one of the major hits to EQ is the low pop of true noobs.
On Fen I recently made a SK, I have honestly yet to group with anyone that wasn't twinked to high heaven. It' just the way it goes.

But, there is a solution.
Recruit!

EQ should, and I honestly don't know if they do now, offer some kind of an incentive to players who bring in new accounts.
They should also apply this to new account holders who open a new account as a result of a player with an existing account. So everybody wins.

I am pleased to see that there are many old school players who have started to return. Perhaps the week that it took to get to 60 in WoW, and the fact that there is like 1 zone for high level raids has lost its appeal.
At least, I'm seeing this on Fen.

If you feel as though the game is dieing, then recruit new players.
WoW had no trouble with this. I saw people who never would have thought about playing EQ running to the stores to purchase, and play WoW.
The hype in GI etc helped that mad rush, but people helped as well.

Recruit recruit recruit. Talk to people you work with, get them excited about the game, then they'll tell two people, and they'll tell...you get the picture.

Just my 2cp.

Thanks.

also, and I just thought of this after I closed my browser,
when was the last time you saw a commercial on TV for EQ?
Yes well, me neither. So its kinda like wth is up with that?
SOE has the dough I'm thinkin to put together something pretty sweet. I bet a months worth of average rotation on major stations would bring a whole buttload of new players in.
Ponder, why does SOE not advertise EQ on TV??

Edited, Tue Aug 16 12:38:19 2005 by CraigD
#9 Aug 16 2005 at 12:00 PM Rating: Decent
I've just cancelled my 3 accounts as well :( - they run out at the end of this month. Nothing at all against EQ its just that most of the folks I "grew-up" with have quit so it really got boring running around solo doing the same ol stuff all the time.

I just picked up Guild Wars and been having fun so far with it. Kinda waiting around for D&D online and/or Vanguard.
#10 Aug 16 2005 at 3:46 PM Rating: Decent
Lots of good stuff here, and i do really miss the game

I am one of those people who has played EQ in the past but stopped for awhile to try other games (FFXI, WoW). However, I've found FFXI to be more like a second job and WoW to be way too easy. Plus, in both of those games, i just haven't found the sense of community i always found in EQ.

So it is extremely hard for me to come back to EQ and see the old world zones empty and not many people around. One good thing that really got my spirits up was last night there was a whopping 37 people in the tutorial! This was on Maelin Starpyre server, and it truly brought a smile to my face :)

But as for the tv commercials, I agree! SOE certainly has the money and resources to do even a moderate advertising campaign for the game. Can't say they've given up on it if they are still releasing expansions, you know? As for graphics, that isn't an issue for me. I've never really cared about graphics, I'm one of those people who will play games like Nexus, Graal and FF Tactics until the day I die, even if the graphics are outdated. So the graphics in EQ are fine for me, but I do agree that perhaps a slight lift will make more people pay some attention to the game!
#11 Aug 16 2005 at 4:18 PM Rating: Excellent
Liberal Conspiracy
*******
TILT
The tutorial is, of course, part of the reason for the newbie zones being empty. By the time you hit lvl 10+ in Gloomingdeep and wander out into the world, you don't have much reason to kick around GFay or QHills or ECommons. And given that Gloomingdeep spits you out into PoK, you don't even have a pressing reason to visit Freeport, Kelethin, etc right away.

Which is kind of a shame since you could be a human paladin of Mithaniel Marr and get to level 20+ without even knowing about N. Freeport but, at the same time, it means true newbies who start will enter the hustle and bustle of PoK instead of the windswept empty streets of Erudin.
____________________________
Belkira wrote:
Wow. Regular ol' Joph fan club in here.
#12 Aug 19 2005 at 10:13 AM Rating: Decent
Having not created a new character in EQ in years, I had no idea there was a whole tutorial section now. Is it like the Isle of Refuge on EQ2?

I do miss EQ a lot though. I have so many fond memories. I still have an active account though through my Station Pass. I keep meaning to get back into it, but sometimes I only have about an hour or less to play and something like WoW makes it feel like I've accomplished something. With EQ the most I can do in an hour is run to a good hunting spot then log. It takes much more time per session to get anything meaningful done. Unfortunately, even when I have a few hours to kill, I usually end up playing WoW. I wish I had time for all of them. :(
#13 Aug 19 2005 at 10:53 AM Rating: Decent
I was thinking of something they might do to/for EQ in a future expansion that might breathe some life into this game again for many.

It is a drastic change and probably wouldn't be popular with some, especially those with strong ties to their toons.

I propose some cataclysmal event for EQ where life as we know it has been totally destroyed. Perhaps some wizards foresaw it coming and got together to cast a grand spell in an attempt to ward off the disaster. In my vision, as a result of this spell, citizens of Norrath and the moon (only those who buy this expansion) are ripped from place and time and are set down onto a Norrath that no longer is recognizable as the same place. Perhaps "some" of their equipment survives the translocation (random items on their person, all in bank lost forever). Perhaps it is still Norrath, but diffent time, or perhaps it is some "different" location where not only is the geography different, but many of their spells no longer work (or work diffently).

So in a nutshell, EQ goes on for all that don't buy this expansion. For those who do, their toon(s)are taken through some storyline at the beginning and then dropped into the new world.....

#14 Aug 19 2005 at 11:20 AM Rating: Good
***
2,198 posts
Kanador wrote:
I was thinking of something they might do to/for EQ in a future expansion that might breathe some life into this game again for many.

It is a drastic change and probably wouldn't be popular with some, especially those with strong ties to their toons.

I propose some cataclysmal event for EQ where life as we know it has been totally destroyed. Perhaps some wizards foresaw it coming and got together to cast a grand spell in an attempt to ward off the disaster. In my vision, as a result of this spell, citizens of Norrath and the moon (only those who buy this expansion) are ripped from place and time and are set down onto a Norrath that no longer is recognizable as the same place. Perhaps "some" of their equipment survives the translocation (random items on their person, all in bank lost forever). Perhaps it is still Norrath, but diffent time, or perhaps it is some "different" location where not only is the geography different, but many of their spells no longer work (or work diffently).

So in a nutshell, EQ goes on for all that don't buy this expansion. For those who do, their toon(s)are taken through some storyline at the beginning and then dropped into the new world.....


Isn't that the buyline for EQII?
#15 Aug 19 2005 at 11:22 AM Rating: Default
Word for word.

Ok, not really, but how much closer can you get without plagiarism?

Yeah, I think they just need to fix and revamp like mad, make things more appealing and somehow bring back that spark that so many of us had when the game first came out.
#16 Aug 19 2005 at 11:58 AM Rating: Good
***
2,198 posts
Quote:
Quote:

the crusade[sic] of Ben Stein against EQ




This peaked my interest. I'm a fan of Ben Stein, but never heard of him being anti-eq. Can you post a link?


A report by G4

And apparently, EQ really isn't the cause of those "EQ suicides" (as we all suspected). No, it was actually the fault of that damn blinking harddrive light!
#17 Aug 19 2005 at 11:58 AM Rating: Decent
I never bought or played EQ II, since most EQ'ers say it sucks. As for it being the basis for EQ II, my idea might be, but I don't want to change the rules for EQ like I hear they have for EQ II. I never really thought of EQ II as an "expansion" for EQ. I thought they took EQ a different direction totally to be more like WoW or other popular multiplayer games out competing with EQ.

I mean same game engine. Same mechanics (except perhaps new/different spells more appropriate for whatever world you pop out into). I wasn't aware that EQ II let you keep any of the stuff on your current toon and take that same toon on into the new game either....
#18 Aug 19 2005 at 1:15 PM Rating: Decent
**
274 posts
your pet will lose its power to 'tank' mobs, instead you can snare the mob and dot it so it will chase you and your pet can beat on it while you run around in circles. This is better than fearing too because you can control where the mob goes so it wont agro its friends.
#19 Aug 19 2005 at 1:41 PM Rating: Decent
Quote:
I was thinking of something they might do to/for EQ in a future expansion that might breathe some life into this game again for many.

It is a drastic change and probably wouldn't be popular with some, especially those with strong ties to their toons.

I propose some cataclysmal event for EQ where life as we know it has been totally destroyed. Perhaps some wizards foresaw it coming and got together to cast a grand spell in an attempt to ward off the disaster. In my vision, as a result of this spell, citizens of Norrath and the moon (only those who buy this expansion) are ripped from place and time and are set down onto a Norrath that no longer is recognizable as the same place. Perhaps "some" of their equipment survives the translocation (random items on their person, all in bank lost forever). Perhaps it is still Norrath, but diffent time, or perhaps it is some "different" location where not only is the geography different, but many of their spells no longer work (or work diffently).

So in a nutshell, EQ goes on for all that don't buy this expansion. For those who do, their toon(s)are taken through some storyline at the beginning and then dropped into the new world.....


and then I take a hit of acid and ... ooops I already did. **** maybe I'll just listen to the Dark side of the moon at half speed.
#20 Aug 19 2005 at 2:18 PM Rating: Decent
Heheh....I wasn't expecting accolades...it's not an original idea by any means.....I just want that feeling I had when I first played EQ, back on Day 1. Everything was new and I was afraid to go too far too fast because no one REALLY knew anything about what was out there.

(I know, there still were the people who played in beta, but.....)

I like the way EQ is now, so I don't want too much change...

I still want a ranger to be a ranger. I don't want an enchanter to be an enchanter...and not devolved into a 3rd rate nuker...

but since we have all these cool items in the game now, any new item introduced has to have awesome stats or no one wants to go find a way to go get it. Old world zones are underplayed because the stuff that drops there doesn't compare to the new stuff. 5 expansions from now no one will go to OOW zones...and the new stuff dropping will have +200 int or +100,000 hps because they have to keep outdoing the stuff they came out with last time...

I miss we all band together to stay alive.... instead of we got together to go grind and kill that same thing over and over and over...

#21 Aug 19 2005 at 2:45 PM Rating: Good
****
6,760 posts
I guess my biggest gripe with how EQ changed over the years is the separation between the casual player and the hard-core. It really is a different game for those that were able to put in 30-40 hours a week and grind out AA's and basically be maxed in gear, keys/flags, and exp (whether AA or just levels) versus the more casual player who was always a few levels behind when the next expansion hit.

Though, for some people, that was what they liked about it. For me, I just felt I was always playing catch-up. It got to be a chore trying to catch up to guildies rather than just logging on and having some fun like when the game first came out.

But, looking back on my 5 years of playing (I cancelled my account in December) I realize it was a great game. And I had some fun. But I know now that it did affect my personal life no matter how much I said it didn't at the time, and I'm glad I don't play anymore. Life is a lot better if you're not spending every free hour behind the computer.

That said, if a new game came out with the potential that EQ had on it's day of release, I'd be hard put not to check it out.

Smiley: sly
____________________________
Some people are like slinkies, they aren't really good for anything, but they still bring a smile to your face when you push them down the stairs.
#22 Aug 19 2005 at 11:24 PM Rating: Decent
I dont think it would be that hard to upgrade the old zones, I mean they seem to pull it off pretty easy for the Fabled Mobs. I would say just increase the curve in the old zones people will go there.

Thanks to tutorial places like Qhills, EC, and Misty Thicket may never be used again and can probably be left off the list. But, other zones like NRO lets say make it that derv rings are worth 2pp to vendor or that their stats are like 5 ac 5str like or something instead of 1 ac 2dex, make that dorn dagger like 10/20 ratio with a lower level weaker proc like fleeting fury or something at level 9.

The new newbie armor quests dont work either I have done about 6 of em on a baby necro ( I wanted a frog ) I made on another server. In most cases I was underskilled til I levelled up to take on what I needed to kill for my next 1ac 2int 5m/h/e item (best AC so far was 5 too. Funny too that these are level restricted =P). So I would try it 2 or 3 times die, go out level a couple levels come back try it again and pull it off, and then get rewarded with an item that was worth less then I could have farmed money and expierence for in the same time. I will admit there is a feeling of accomplishment but geesh.

Example on the level 12 newbie quest: (this only one actually good for your level as far as what you have to kill) kill 5 sand scarab, loot eggsack off sand scarab, kill five dune tarantula, loot one spider venom sack, kill 5 giant snakes all this in NRO zone. Scarabs were easy, turns out that sand scarab hatchlings count as sand scarabs so like 5-10 minutes to run from FP to NRO and 5-10 minutes hunting I have 2 of tasks done, giant snakes a lil harder as they are a lil rarer. But Dune Tarantulas are a mother.... super rare spawn, like 1-2 every 30 minutes. Continuing everforward though I have in about 45-60 minutes more killed the snakes and the tarantulas I need,but no venom sack.

Well it became a pride thing, roaming all over NRO killing anything that moved and getting excited everytime it was a spider. I ended up with 5 stacks of spiderling silk, 5 stacks of spider silk, 2 levels and 1 fargin spider venom sack that dropped off a desert tarantula not a dune tarantula that the quest decided to count, thank god. (8 hours in NRO for that, not the other stuff just the stupid sack)So my level 12 armor quest counting running to and from pok took me about 9 and 1/2 hours.

I could have spent 91/2 hours in PC and gotten to level 24 with around 200-300pp easy, or If I wanted to farm spiders I could have done FoB or Ferrort and gotten like 3x that at least. Doing the newbie quests I have found I cannot afford all my spells right away, and get worse for my return then if I had farmed tradeskill stuff and set up a trader or just gone straight experience and bought everything in the bazaar. I worked for 91/2 hours to get a 1 ac 3 int 5/h/m/e ring when I could have gotten a moonstone ring for 10pp. (which is like 3ac 30 mana iirc) Only good thing I can say about these quests is that it did take me to parts of RM and WW I had never been too and let me revisit a few haunts like chessboard in BB.

So ya the new newbie armor quests suck and to be honest the nostalgia so far hasnt done it for me. To me they are just as bad as the old ones done in the newbie zones off the newbie towns that no one even goes to anymore. Still kinda funny Sony callin them your starting cities... kinda depressing too for those of us who been there. Anymore those cities are kinda like Katta Kastellem... you really only run there if you need something that can only be gotten from there.
#24 Aug 20 2005 at 10:50 AM Rating: Good
***
1,907 posts
I think the cost of starting up EQ is very daunting to a new player. There is no way I'd pay the up front costs of all the expansions, plus a monthly fee when I have no idea if I'd like it or not. And I wouldn't want to start with a few expansions, knowing how many there are.

They need a 30 day free period (at least) with all expansions, then a way to buy all the expansions without paying over $100. Maybe they could charge $2/month for use of all the expansions or something. Maybe they could sell a test game pack with all expansions for $30. You want to try Guild Wars or other games the original cost is not as great as EQ. EQ was a reasonable cost for trying it years ago, it's nuts now.

EQ needs new players. They could limit levels maybe on free play, like 35 if you are playing for free, or limit other things, while still giving a quality test. The veteran's benefits are a good encouragemetn to pay. They could have other things you only get if you pay.
Reply To Thread

Colors Smileys Quote OriginalQuote Checked Help

 

Recent Visitors: 84 All times are in CST
Anonymous Guests (84)